Source: 📒 The development of media truth discernment and fake news detection is related to the development of reasoning during adolescence
📜🔗LINK
Number of pages: 10
1. ANALYTICAL SUMMARY
Context, audiences, and issues
The article starts from the observation that online fake news represents a major threat to democracy (elections, COVID-19, climate, war in Ukraine), while most of the work focuses on adults and very little on adolescents. The authors remind us that nearly 95% of American adolescents own a smartphone by the age of 13, spend more than an hour a day on social media, and get more information from platforms than from traditional news media. In this context, the study raises the question of the development, from the age of 11 to adulthood, of the ability to distinguish between true and false information, and the role of analytical reasoning (dual process theories, System 1 / System 2) in this evolution. It also examines the 'illusory truth effect', which is the tendency to judge repeated information as more true, regardless of its factual content. [23:24 in article]
Operational contributions for the field
The study provides fine developmental data on 564 participants (432 secondary school students aged 11 to 14, 132 young adults) who assessed the truthfulness of 56 news headlines as true or false and completed a cognitive reflection test (CRT). It shows that the ability to discern between true and false increases linearly with age, that the capacity to judge truth and falsehood appears from the age of 12, and that analytical reasoning mediates a significant part of this progression, particularly for the detection of fake news. In parallel, the effect of repetition (illusory truth) is already present at age 11, stable into adulthood, and stronger for fake news than for true news, but independent of reasoning abilities. For practitioners, these results guide the design of media literacy actions: early interventions from the start of secondary school, explicit work on analytical reasoning, and measures to reduce the effects of repetition and familiarity.
2. KEY POINTS OF THE DOCUMENT
Fake news as a structural threat and under-exploration of teenagers (p.1–2)
The article places fake news in a global context (American and Brazilian elections, COVID-19, climate, war in Ukraine) and reminds us that most research focuses on adults, even though teenagers are massively connected and exposed to news content via social media. It highlights the paradox between young people's stated confidence in their ability to assess the credibility of information and their difficulties in detecting conflicts of interest or sponsored content.
Robust experimental design with 56 news headlines and manipulation of repetition (p.2, p.6–7)
The authors use 28 true headlines from mainstream media and 28 false headlines from fact-checking sites, all free from text length bias and separated from their original source to neutralise the effect of the media brand. Participants evaluate the interest of half of the headlines (exposure), then the veracity of all 56 headlines, which allows for the calculation of a discernment score (true – false) and an illusory truth score (repeated – new).
Linear progression of discernment and emergence of true/false from the age of 12 (p.2–3)
The analyses (ANOVA, polynomial trends) show a linear increase in the discernment score between the ages of 11 and adulthood, with two significant thresholds: between 12 and 13 years, and then between 14 years and adults. At 11 years, young people do not significantly distinguish between true and false news, whereas all other age groups — from the age of 12 — judge true information as more accurate than false.
Specific role of analytical reasoning in detecting fake news (p.3–4)
Performance on the CRT is correlated with overall discernment and, specifically, with the ability to reduce the accuracy ratings given to fake news, with a significant mediating effect of these scores between age and discernment. Mediation by the CRT is strong for fake news and non-existent for true news, suggesting that the detection of falsehood relies more on analytical reasoning, while the recognition of truth also engages other processes (knowledge, media literacy).
Illusory truth effect present at all ages, stronger for fake news and independent of the CRT (p.4–5)
The repetition effect is observed from the age of 11 to adulthood: in all groups, previously seen headlines are judged to be more accurate than new headlines, with a significant effect size. This effect is slightly more pronounced for fake news than for true news and shows no significant association with the CRT or with the discernment score, which supports a mechanism of perceptual fluency rather than a reasoning deficit.
3. ACTION POINTS FOR LOCAL ACTORS
Implement targeted media literacy modules from Year 6 on true/false (p.2–3, p.6–7)
Data shows that at 11 years old, students do not yet distinguish between true and false information, but can do so from the age of 12, which supports systematic educational sequences at the beginning of secondary school on identifying fake news and distinguishing content/source. Educational teams can rely on sessions for judging headlines (real vs. fake) constructed on the model of the experimental task.
Integrate analytical reasoning exercises into media workshops (p.3–4, p.7–8)
As the CRT mediates a significant part of the progression of discernment, especially for detecting falsehoods, it is relevant to integrate simplified CRT-type tasks (short problems, misleading intuitive answers) into media literacy or debate workshops. The goal is to teach young people to "be wary" of their first intuition and to take a few seconds to verify the consistency of information before believing or sharing it.
Work explicitly on the repetition effect and familiarity (p.4–5)
Given that repetition makes information more credible at all ages, and especially for fake news, it is essential to offer sequences where young people experience this effect themselves: repeated exposure to statements, followed by discussion on how familiarity alters judgment. [in article] Existing educational tools on 'fake news' and conspiracy theories can be mobilised (escape games, interactive exhibitions, dedicated platforms).
Articulating Media and Information Literacy, disciplinary knowledge, and general culture (p.5–6)
The authors acknowledge that the progression of discernment cannot be explained solely by reasoning and that knowledge of the subjects addressed can also play a role. This supports interdisciplinary approaches that combine Media and Information Literacy, sciences, history-geography, or social and economic sciences to strengthen foundational knowledge that helps to recognise the plausible and the implausible.
Adapting the devices to the limits of the study (age, materials, familiarity) (p.5–7)
The sample mainly covers ages 11–14 and young adults, and the same titles have been used for all, which may advantage the older participants in terms of knowledge. Local actors will benefit from adapting the content (themes, formats, platforms) to the actual uses of the young people involved, checking the familiarity of the information used, and combining reasoning measurement with digital culture identification.
4. ADDITIONAL REFERENCES
🔍➕ For more information, see the articles referenced by "Health Practices" on the theme of digital ➡️🔗https://pratiquesensante.odoo.com/2-6-intelligence-artificielle-numeriqueand on the theme of literacy ➡️🔗https://pratiquesensante.odoo.com/1-4-litteratie-en-sante-falc
5. CROSS-ANALYSIS — PRACTICAL VALUES IN HEALTH
Literacy: The document uses scientific language but proposes simple tasks (rating titles on a scale of 1–4) that can inspire tools accessible at different levels of understanding.
Empowerment: The study does not describe co-design with young people, but its results support programmes aimed at strengthening their active capacity for critical judgement.
Participation: Adolescents are here subjects of study, not co-actors in the construction of the devices, and no structured participatory approach is described.
Community health: The collective dimension is addressed implicitly through democratic issues and the risks of mass misinformation, but without a detailed community intervention framework.
Ethics: The protocol adheres to ethical standards (IRB, parental consent), but cultural and social biases in exposure to fake news are only mentioned in the background.
Human rights: The text highlights the risks to democracy and the need to strengthen young people's ability to protect themselves against misinformation, which aligns with the principles of equitable access to reliable information.
Intersectorality: The article mentions media, digital platforms, and schools as contexts, without detailing formalised partnerships between sectors.
Partnership: No structured model of collaboration (school-media-health-justice) is developed, with the text remaining focused on psychological experimentation.
Combating discrimination: The document does not directly address discrimination or diversity, but its issues regarding political and health fake news can be linked to inequalities in access to reliable information.
6. EVALUATION OF THE RELIABILITY OF THE RESOURCE
Scientific relevance
Article published inScientific Reports, an international open access peer-reviewed journal, indexed and linked to Nature Portfolio.
Clear methodology: large sample (N=564), detailed description of tasks, statistical analyses (ANOVAs, partial correlations, mediations with bootstrap), indication of effect sizes.
Updated references on fake news, the illusory truth effect, and the CRT, including recent reviews (Brashier & Marsh 2020, Pennycook & Rand 2021).
Data and materials available in open science on OSF.
→ High scientific relevance.
Operational relevance
The resource remains an article of experimental psychology: no ready-to-use kit, but results directly transposable into educational objectives (target age, role of reasoning, effects of repetition).
It is particularly useful for advocating EMI programmes and interventions aimed at developing analytical thinking in 11–15 year olds.
→ Good operational relevance, provided there is appropriation work by field teams.
7. MCQ — 5 QUESTIONS
PART 1 — Questions (without answers)
Question 1 (p.1–2)
What was one of the main objectives of this study?
a) To measure the time spent on social media by adolescents
b) To study the development of discernment between true and false news from adolescence to adulthood
c) Evaluate the impact of parents on the political opinions of adolescents
d) Test the effect of fact-checking campaigns on adult voting
Question 2 (p.2–3)
At what age do the authors first observe a significant distinction between true and false news in the judgments of participants?
a) 11 years old
b) 12 years old
c) 15 years old
d) 18 years old
Question 3 (p.3–4)
What role does the Cognitive Reflection Test (CRT) play in this study?
a) It measures reaction time to news headlines
b) It assesses long-term memory of the information read
c) It serves as an indicator of analytical reasoning mediating the link between age and media discernment
d) It only measures the political knowledge of participants
Question 4 (p.4–5)
What is the "illusory truth effect" as described in the article?
a) The tendency to automatically reject any information already seen
b) The tendency to judge previously encountered information as more accurate
c) The ability to remember true information rather than false
d) The fact that only adults are sensitive to fake news
Question 5 (p.5–7)
What is one of the limitations acknowledged by the authors?
a) The sample does not include any adults
b) Participants had unlimited access to the internet during the task
c) The same news headlines were presented to adolescents and adults, which may involve differences in general knowledge.
d) The fake news headlines came from the participants' social media.
PART 2 — Commented correction
Question 1 (p.1–2)
✅ Correct answer: b) To study the development of discernment between true and false news from adolescence to adulthood.
📝 Explanation: The authors explicitly state that they seek to understand how the ability to distinguish between true and false information develops from the age of 11 to adulthood, and how this evolution relates to reasoning.
Question 2 (p.2–3)
✅ Correct answer: b) 12 years.
📝 Explanation: Analyses show that at 11 years old, participants do not significantly differentiate between true and false headlines, while this distinction appears from the age of 12, and then improves linearly with age.
Question 3 (p.3–4)
✅ Correct answer: c) It serves as an indicator of analytical reasoning mediating the link between age and media discernment.
📝 Explanation: The CRT is used to operationalise analytical reasoning (the shift from system 1 to system 2), and mediation analyses show that it explains part of the link between age and discernment score, especially for detecting fake news.
Question 4 (p.4–5)
✅ Correct answer: b) The tendency to judge information previously encountered as more accurate.
📝 Explanation: The illusory truth effect is defined as an increase in the perception of truthfulness for repeated information, regardless of its actual status, and the study shows this effect in 11–14 year olds as well as in adults.
Question 5 (p.5–7)
✅ Correct answer: c) The same news headlines were presented to both adolescents and adults, which may involve differences in general knowledge.
📝 Explanation: The authors acknowledge that using the same material for all ages may favour adults, who have a broader knowledge base, even though they selected topics presumed to be familiar to adolescents.
8. FAQ
Why does this study specifically focus on adolescents? (p.1–2)
The authors highlight that adolescents are heavily equipped with smartphones, are very active on social media, and are exposed to current news through these platforms, whereas most work on fake news focuses on adults.
How were the fake news items selected for the study? (p.6–7)
The 28 fake news headlines come from fact-checking sites (e.g., factuel.afp.com) and have been verified as false, then presented without their original source to neutralise the impact of the media brand on judgments.
What does the 'media truth discernment' score measure exactly? (p.2–3, p.7)
It is the difference between the average accuracy rating given to true headlines and that given to false headlines, normalised; a score close to 1 indicates a good ability to distinguish true from false, while a score close to 0 indicates a poor ability.
Are all age groups sensitive to the illusory truth effect? (p.4–5)
Yes, the study shows that 11-year-olds, 12-year-olds, 13-year-olds, 14-year-olds, and adults consistently judge previously seen headlines as more accurate than new headlines, with a significant effect size for all groups.
Does analytical reasoning also protect against the illusory truth effect? (p.4–5)
No, CRT scores are not significantly correlated with the illusory truth effect, suggesting that this effect depends more on familiarity and processing fluency than on analytical reasoning abilities.
Do the results mean that teenagers share more fake news than adults? (p.5–6)
Not necessarily: the authors remind us that judging information as true or false is not directly related to sharing intentions and cite studies showing that older adults proportionally share more fake news than young adults.
How can these results guide a local media literacy programme? (p.5–7)
The study suggests targeting interventions at the transition to secondary school to establish discernment skills, integrating analytical reasoning activities, and making the repetition effect on gullibility explicit in practical workshops or educational games.
9. REWRITING IN EASY TO READ LANGUAGE
EASY TO READ TITLE
Understanding true and false information among young people
EASY TO READ SUMMARY
Young people see a lot of information on the internet and social media.
Sometimes, this information is false and can harm society.
Researchers wanted to see at what age young people differentiate between true and false.
They also looked at how young people's reasoning helps to identify false information.
564 people participated, including many secondary school students.
Each person read headlines of true articles and false headlines.
They had to say whether each headline seemed accurate or not, on a simple scale.
Then, they answered small logic problems.
Key points FALC
1. At 11 years old, true and false are still mixed up
11-year-olds do not see the difference well between true and false headlines.
Young people aged 12 and older are better at making this distinction.
2. The older you get, the better you spot the false
The ability to spot falsehoods improves with age.
Adults are better than teenagers at distinguishing true from false.
3. Reasoning especially helps to spot the false
When young people take the time to think, they better identify false information.
Small logic tests show who uses more reflection.
This reflection explains part of the progression with age.
4. Repeating information makes it more credible for everyone
When a headline has been seen before, people find it more true.
This happens even if the headline is false.
This effect is present in both young people and adults.
5. Repetition has nothing to do with the level of logic
Being good at logic does not eliminate the effect of repetition.
The brain likes what is familiar to it and judges it to be more true.